Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price Video Games and Consoles for a Garage Sale

Most common disc or cartridge games sell for $3-$15 at a garage sale, older common games for $2-$10, newer popular games for $5-$30, and a working console with a controller and cables for $40-$150. Garage sale buyers pay cash for as-is items, so price below online sold prices and expect some haggling. Our garage sale pricing guide covers the general approach if you are pricing a whole table of goods.

Video game and console garage sale price table

Use these ranges as a starting point, then adjust for condition and what is included. A game that works and has its case is worth more than a loose disc that may not play.

ItemTypical garage sale priceNotes
Video game (disc or cartridge)$3-$15Test it if you can; loose discs sell lower
Older common game$2-$10Older sports and movie tie-in titles are usually at the low end
Newer or popular game$5-$30Recent releases and family favorites hold value longer
Working console with controller and cables$40-$150Show it powering on and include everything needed to play
Extra controllerPrice lower than the console; test it firstMatch the console brand and check the buttons and sticks
Sealed, rare or vintage gameCheck sold listings before pricingThese can be worth far more than a typical garage sale price

What changes the price of a used game or console?

Two games with the same title can sell for very different amounts depending on how complete and how tested they are. These are the factors buyers check before they hand over cash.

  • It works when tested — a console that powers on and reads a disc or cartridge is worth much more than an untested one
  • Original case and manual — complete games sell faster and for more than loose discs or cartridges
  • Disc scratches — deep scratches or a disc that skips drops the price, so check the surface in good light
  • All cables and a controller included — a console without its power supply or video cable is harder to sell
  • How recent the system is — newer systems still have active buyers and accessories on store shelves
  • Popular family titles sell faster — well-known multiplayer and party games move quickly at a driveway sale

Which video games should you look up before pricing?

Sealed games, vintage cartridge games and complete-in-box games can be worth much more than a typical garage sale price. Before you put a sticker on those, check recent SOLD listings online rather than asking prices, because asking prices are often wishful thinking. If a game looks unusual, has its original shrink wrap or comes from an older system, take a minute to look it up.

For anything that turns out to be valuable, consider selling it online instead of at the sale. You will reach more collectors and usually get a better price, even after fees and shipping. Our guide on garage sale vs Facebook Marketplace helps you decide which channel suits each item.

How to test and display games and consoles

Plug the console in so buyers can see it power on. A small TV or monitor on the table, an extension cord and a power strip make this easy, and a working demo answers more questions than any sign. Keep the extension cord taped down or routed out of the walking path so nobody trips.

Put discs back in their cases after each test and keep cartridges in a shallow tray so they do not roll off the table. Wipe personal data and sign out of accounts, then factory reset the console before the sale. That protects your account details and gives the buyer a clean start.

Keep small games near the checkout table, where you can watch them and answer questions. Loose discs and cartridges are easy to pocket, so do not leave them in an open box at the far end of the driveway. Our guide on how to price electronics covers testing and safety for the rest of your gadgets.

Bundle games to sell more

Sell a console with two or three games as one bundle. A buyer who is setting up a system for the family would rather take everything home at once, and you clear more space from the table. Price the bundle a little below the sum of the parts so it looks like a deal.

Offer common games as "3 for $10"-style deals built from the table prices. Group titles by system and genre so shoppers can see what fits together, and use clear stickers that show the bundle price and what is included. Our bundle pricing calculator does the math, and the printable price stickers make the labels easy to read.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

How much should I sell video games for at a garage sale?

Most common disc or cartridge games sell for $3-$15, older common games for $2-$10 and newer or popular games for $5-$30. Price loose or scratched discs at the low end and complete, tested games toward the top of the range.

How much is a used game console worth at a garage sale?

A working console with a controller and cables typically sells for $40-$150. Condition, the model and the accessories included move the price within that range, so test it and show it powering on before you sticker it.

Should I sell old video games at a garage sale or online?

Sell common games at the garage sale and check sealed, vintage or complete-in-box titles against recent sold listings first. Valuable games often do better online, where collectors will pay closer to the going rate.

Should I reset a console before selling it?

Yes. Sign out of your accounts, wipe personal data and factory reset the console before the sale. That removes your profile and payment details and gives the buyer a clean system to set up.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.