Garage Sale Toys & Games Prices: What to Charge

Toys and games are steady sellers at garage sales because families outgrow them fast and collectors hunt for complete sets. LEGO, board games and video games bring the most when everything is together and buyers can see they work. Sort LEGO by complete sets versus bulk loose bricks, bag small parts in clear zip bags, and put fresh batteries in anything that lights up or makes noise. Price outdoor and ride-on toys individually and note any wear or missing pieces on the tag.

Typical toys & games prices

Item	Typical price	Notes
LEGO (loose, per lb)	$4–$10
LEGO set (boxed, complete)	$15–$60	Check sold listings for sealed or vintage sets.
Board game (complete)	$2–$8
Jigsaw puzzle (complete)	$1–$5	Check for missing pieces before pricing.
Action figure	$1–$8
Doll	$2–$10
Stuffed animal	$1–$5
Video game (disc or cartridge)	$3–$15	Check sold listings for sealed or vintage sets.
Outdoor toy	$5–$25
Ride-on toy	$15–$40

Find toys & games at garage sales

Use these price ranges while shopping to compare asking prices, check an item's condition and decide what to offer.

Browse kids & toys garage sales near you to find sales to visit.

Selling instead? Post your garage sale.

Pricing tips for toys & games

Put batteries in toys that light up or make noise so buyers can test them on the spot.
Bag small parts, dice and game pieces in clear zip bags and tape them to the box.
Sort LEGO into labelled bins for complete sets versus loose bulk by the pound.
Open jigsaw puzzles and confirm all pieces are there before you price them.

Want more detail? Read our full guide: How to price toys and baby gear at a garage sale.

Common questions

How much should I sell LEGO for at a garage sale?

Loose LEGO often sells for about $4 to $10 per pound. A complete boxed set in good shape might sell for about $15 to $60; sealed or retired sets can be worth more if you check sold listings first.

How much should I charge for used board games?

A complete board game with all pieces usually sells for about $2 to $8. Popular family games in great shape can be at the higher end; games missing pieces should be priced lower or sold as craft parts.

Do video games sell at garage sales?

Yes. Discs and cartridges in working cases often sell for about $3 to $15. Look up rare or sealed titles before pricing them, and test discs on your console when you can.