Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price Board Games & Puzzles at a Garage Sale

Most used board games sell for $2-$5 and jigsaw puzzles for $1-$3 at a garage sale. Complete, popular modern hobby games such as Catan and Ticket to Ride can bring $8-$20, and missing pieces cut the price sharply.

This guide gives you a price chart by game type, a simple way to show a game is complete, and a check for the games worth looking up before sale day. For the wider category, see how to price toys and baby items, how to price Hot Wheels, Barbies and vintage toys and the Toys & Games price guide.

Board game and puzzle price chart

Use these ranges as starting prices for clean games and puzzles with all the main pieces. Complete copies and popular titles sit toward the top, while missing pieces, worn boxes and damaged puzzles push prices toward the bottom or into a bundle.

ItemTypical priceWhat to check
Classic family games (Monopoly, Scrabble, Clue)$2-$5All pieces, cards and instructions; box condition
Modern hobby/strategy games$8-$20Complete components, edition and box condition
Card games (Uno, decks)$1-$3Full deck, all cards present, box or tin
Kids' games$1-$3Pieces, rules and working parts
Jigsaw puzzles (500-1000 pcs)$1-$3Count the pieces or note any missing
Sealed/new-in-shrink games and puzzlesMore than open copiesShrink wrap, edition and any shelf wear
Vintage games from the 1960s-80sLook up sold listingsCompleteness, edition, box and piece condition

How to show a game is complete

Count the pieces against the parts list in the rules, then bag the loose pieces in a clear zip bag so buyers can see what is inside. Tape the box shut and write 'complete' on the tag, or 'missing X' if something is gone. A clear label saves shoppers from opening every box and tells them you checked.

For puzzles, count the pieces or at least confirm the count matches the box, and note any missing pieces on the tag. If a game is missing a lot, sell it as a craft or parts box at a low price rather than as a playable game.

Which games are worth a closer look

Pull out sealed games, popular modern hobby titles, older editions and anything that looks unusual before you put it in the cheap pile. Check the edition, publisher and completeness, then compare recent sold listings for the same version and condition rather than asking prices.

A famous title alone does not make a game valuable. Common family games from the 1970s-90s were made in huge numbers, so condition and completeness matter more than age. When a game looks promising, research it before tagging and price the rest simply.

Bundling and display tips

Stand boxes upright so shoppers can read the titles, and keep puzzles stacked flat with the piece count facing out. Group kids' games together and offer a bundle price such as three games for $5 to clear duplicates.

At the end of the day, bundle whatever is left into a single low price or a fill-a-box deal. For more display ideas, see how to price garage sale items.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

Do people buy used puzzles at a garage sale?

Yes. Jigsaw puzzles usually sell for $1-$3 when the piece count is checked and any missing pieces are noted. Sealed puzzles and popular images sell fastest, and a low bundle price helps clear the rest.

Should I sell games with missing pieces?

You can, but be honest and price them low. Write 'missing X' on the tag, or sell incomplete games as a parts or craft box. Missing pieces cut the price sharply compared with a complete copy.

How much is a used Monopoly game worth?

A complete used Monopoly game usually sells for about $2-$5 at a garage sale. Sealed, older or unusual editions can be worth more, so check sold listings for the exact edition before pricing those.

Are vintage board games valuable?

Some are, but most common vintage games from the 1960s-80s were made in large numbers and sell for modest prices. Completeness, edition and box condition matter most, so look up sold listings for the exact game before you tag it.

Can I bundle games at a garage sale?

Yes. Bundling works well for common family games, kids' games and puzzles. Try a price like three games for $5, and keep sealed or collectible games separate so buyers can see them.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.