Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price CDs and Cassette Tapes at a Garage Sale

Most CDs sell for $1-$2 each and cassette tapes for $1-$3 each, or $5-$10 for a full box at a garage sale. Box sets, sealed cassettes and rare-band pressings can bring more, so check those first. For VHS tapes, see how to price VHS tapes.

Condition and rarity decide the price, so check that discs are not deeply scratched and that the right tape is in each case before you tag them. For the wider category table, see the books, media and music price guide, how to price books, DVDs and records and how to price vinyl records.

CD and cassette tape price chart

These are starting prices for clean, complete tapes and discs in good condition. Adjust down for warped cassette shells, missing labels or discs that skip, and check sold listings before pricing anything that might be a rare or sealed release.

ItemTypical garage sale priceWorth more if
Music cassettes$1-$3Complete with the case, no warped shell
Sealed or rare-band cassettes$5-$20Unopened, first pressings or limited releases
Walkman/cassette player$10-$30Plays cleanly, battery compartment intact, cord included
Common CDs$1-$2Disc and case match, no deep scratches
Box set CDs$5-$15Complete set with all discs and booklet
Box deal for a full box$5-$10Large mixed box of CDs and cassettes at one price
Common movie VHS50 cents-$2For sealed, horror and Disney tapes, see how to price VHS tapes

Are my CDs and cassette tapes worth anything?

Most CDs and cassettes are worth the everyday prices above, but a few sell for more. Check sold listings before you tag any of these:

  • Sealed cassettes and first pressings from bands that collectors follow.
  • Complete CD box sets with every disc and the original booklet.
  • Rare-band cassettes that were never reissued on CD or streaming.
  • Promo copies, imports and limited releases with their original labels.
  • Check SOLD listings, not asking prices, before you tag anything that might be one of these.

How to display and sell CDs and cassettes

  • Line CDs and cassettes up in a box with the spines facing out so buyers can read the titles without digging.
  • Test a few discs and tapes and say so on the sign, because a working sample builds trust for the whole box.
  • Use a flat price per item or a fill-a-bag deal so buyers do not haggle over each disc or tape.
  • Keep the sealed, box-set and rare cassettes near you and price them individually instead of putting them in the bulk box.
  • Check that each disc and tape matches its case before the sale, so buyers are not disappointed.

What to do with CDs and cassettes that don't sell

CDs and cassettes that sit through the sale are easy to move on. Donate them to a thrift store or library, offer a free box of them to the first person who asks, or pass clean playable tapes to a community group that still uses them. Most curbside recycling programs do not take tapes, so check your local e-waste rules for the rest. For VHS tapes, see how to price VHS tapes.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

Are old cassette tapes worth anything?

Music cassettes usually sell for about $1 to $3 each, or a few dollars for a box. Sealed tapes, first pressings and rare-band releases can bring $5-$20, so check sold listings before pricing anything that looks rare.

How much should I sell CDs for at a garage sale?

Common CDs sell for about $1 to $2 each, and complete box sets for $5-$15. Offer a box deal for a full box of CDs to clear them out, and check that each disc matches its case before pricing it.

Are CD box sets worth more than single CDs?

Yes, usually. A complete box set with all the discs and the original booklet sells for about $5 to $15 at a garage sale, while a single common CD sells for $1 to $2. Missing discs or a damaged box drop the price.

Do CDs sell at garage sales?

Yes, but at low prices. Common CDs sell for about $1 to $2 each, and box sets for $5-$15. Offer a box deal for a full box of CDs to clear them out, and check that each disc matches its case before pricing it.

Should I sell CDs and cassettes individually or in a lot?

Sell common CDs and cassettes in lots for $5 to $10 a box, because that moves a big pile fast. Pull out sealed, box-set and rare-band pieces and price those individually, since a lot hides their value.

Do cassette players and CD players sell at garage sales?

Yes, if they work. A tested Walkman, boombox or portable CD player usually sells for $10 to $30 at a garage sale. Show it playing, include the headphones or cables, and label it honestly if the buttons or tray are faulty.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.