Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price Collector Plates at a Garage Sale

Most mass-produced collector plates sell for about $1-$5 each at a garage sale. Bradford Exchange, Franklin Mint, Hamilton Collection, Knowles and Norman Rockwell series plates were made in huge numbers, so resale demand is low. The exceptions are older Royal Copenhagen and Bing & Grondahl Christmas plates, some Wedgwood Jasperware, sterling or signed limited pieces, and complete boxed sets. For the wider category, see the Antiques & Collectibles price guide.

Collector plate price chart

Typical garage sale prices for collector plates. The maker, the year and the condition move the price within each range, so check the back stamp and sold listings before you tag anything that looks older.

ItemTypical garage sale priceNotes
Bradford Exchange / Hamilton / Knowles plates$1-$5Box and certificate add a little
Franklin Mint porcelain plates$1-$5Sterling or pewter pieces are worth their metal, so check the mark
Norman Rockwell plates$1-$5Common and widely collected; condition matters more than the series
Royal Copenhagen / Bing & Grondahl Christmas plates (1970s onward)$5-$20Check the year on the back; later years are common
Royal Copenhagen / Bing & Grondahl plates from before 1950$15-$75+Check the year and sold listings
Wedgwood Jasperware Christmas plates$5-$20Blue and green jasperware sell best; chips cut the price
Complete boxed sets or series$10-$40 per setSell as one lot
Plate stands, hangers and display racks$0.50-$5Easy add-ons for plate buyers

Is it a valuable plate? A quick check before you price it

A few minutes with the plate in your hand tells you most of what you need. Work through this checklist before you write a tag.

  • Read the back stamp for the maker, the year and any limited edition number.
  • For Royal Copenhagen and Bing & Grondahl, an older year means a higher value.
  • Look for sterling or pewter marks; metal pieces are worth at least their scrap value.
  • Check for chips, crazing and fading, which all lower the price.
  • An original box and certificate add about $1-$3.
  • Search sold (not asking) listings for the exact plate before pricing it higher.
  • Treat "limited edition" wording as marketing, not rarity.

How to sell collector plates at a garage sale

Price low and bundle common plates, for example 3 for $5, so they move instead of sitting all day. Display the plates upright on stands where shoppers can see the pattern, and offer a whole series as one lot. For valuable older Christmas plates, a dealer, an estate sale or an online sale will usually beat a garage sale price. See our guides to how to price figurines, how to price Pyrex, glassware and china and how to price items for an estate sale.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

Are collector plates worth anything?

Most collector plates are worth about $1 to $5 each at a garage sale. Bradford Exchange, Franklin Mint, Hamilton and Knowles plates were mass-produced, so demand is low. Older Royal Copenhagen and Bing & Grondahl Christmas plates, sterling pieces and complete boxed sets can be worth more.

What collector plates are worth money?

Older Royal Copenhagen and Bing & Grondahl Christmas plates are the standouts, at about $15 to $75 or more for pieces made before 1950. Some Wedgwood Jasperware, sterling or signed limited pieces and complete boxed series also bring more than the usual $1 to $5.

Are Bradford Exchange plates worth anything?

Most Bradford Exchange plates sell for about $1 to $5 at a garage sale. They were made in large numbers and resale demand is low, though an original box and certificate can add about $1 to $3. Check sold listings for a specific plate before pricing it higher.

How much are Royal Copenhagen Christmas plates worth?

Royal Copenhagen and Bing & Grondahl Christmas plates from the 1970s onward usually sell for about $5 to $20. Plates made before 1950 can bring $15 to $75 or more. Check the year on the back stamp and compare sold listings for the exact plate.

What is the best way to sell collector plates?

Bundle common plates at a garage sale, for example 3 for $5, and display them upright on stands. Sell a complete series as one lot. For valuable older Christmas plates, use a dealer, an estate sale or an online sale to reach collectors and get a better price.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.