Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price Pet Supplies at a Garage Sale

Most used pet supplies sell for about 25-40% of the new price at a garage sale: $15-$40 for a dog crate, $5-$15 for a pet bed, $10-$30 for a fish tank, $15-$40 for a cat tree and $1-$3 for bowls, leashes and collars.

Cleanliness and completeness decide the price more than age in this category. For the full category breakdown, see the pet supplies price guide, and for everything else at your sale, see how to price garage sale items.

Pet supplies price chart

These are starting prices for clean, complete items. Mark down for chewing, stains, missing parts or anything that does not work.

ItemTypical garage sale priceWorth more if
Wire dog crate, small/medium (up to 36 in)$15-$25Includes tray, dividers and cover; latches work
Wire dog crate, large/XL (42 in and up)$25-$40Double-door, sturdy, no bent bars, complete tray
Plastic travel kennel / carrier$10-$25All bolts and the door included, no cracks
Soft pet carrier / tote$5-$15Clean fabric, zippers work, no chew damage
Pet bed$5-$15Freshly washed, no stains or chewing, thick cushion
Cat tree / cat condo$15-$40Stable, clean carpet, all platforms and posts intact
Litter box (new or unused only)$3-$8Never used, or sanitized and sold with a scoop
Aquarium 10-20 gal with filter, lid and light$10-$30Tested leak-free; working filter and light included
Large aquarium 40+ gal setup$40-$100+Full setup with stand, filter, heater and lid; leak-tested
Bird cage$10-$30Clean, no rust, includes perches and feeders
Small-animal cage (hamster, guinea pig, rabbit)$10-$25Complete with bottle, bowl, hideout and wheel
Dog gate / exercise pen$10-$25All panels and latches work, clean
Leashes, collars and bowls bundle$3-$10Clean set, metal bowls, no frayed leashes
Unopened pet food and treats$2-$8Sealed and well before the expiry date; never opened bags

Is it clean and safe enough to sell?

Pet items touch animals directly, so buyers judge them on cleanliness and safety first. Run through this check before you tag anything:

  • Wash fabric items — beds, blankets, soft carriers — in hot water and dry them fully.
  • Disinfect plastic and metal — crates, carriers, litter boxes, bowls — with a pet-safe cleaner.
  • Test an aquarium for leaks by filling it with water and leaving it overnight before the sale.
  • Check crate latches, trays and dividers; a crate with a broken latch or missing tray belongs at the low end or in the trash.
  • Never sell opened pet food, medication or flea and tick products — unopened, in-date food only.
  • Check recalls for pet products before you sell, so you are not passing on a recalled item.

How to sell pet supplies faster

  • Bundle a starter kit — a "new puppy kit" with a collar, leash, bowls and a small bed — at one price.
  • Show the crate size in inches and the breed size on the tag ("fits a Labrador") so buyers do not have to guess.
  • Set up the cat tree fully so buyers can see it is stable and complete.
  • For more tagging tricks, see garage sale price tags and labeling ideas.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

How much should I sell a dog crate for at a garage sale?

A sturdy dog crate usually sells for about $15 to $40, depending on size and condition. A large or double-door crate with its tray, dividers and cover brings the top of the range; a bare frame with a broken latch belongs at the low end.

Can I sell opened pet food at a garage sale?

No. Sell only unopened, sealed food and treats that are still well before the expiry date, and never sell opened bags, medication or flea and tick products — they are not safe to pass on secondhand.

How much is a used fish tank worth?

A fish tank or aquarium often sells for about $10 to $30 at a garage sale, and a large 40+ gallon setup with stand, filter, heater and lid can reach $40 to $100 or more. Test it for leaks first — a leaking tank is worth very little.

Should I bundle pet supplies at a garage sale?

Yes for small items: leashes, collars, bowls and toys sell faster as one priced bundle or a "new puppy kit". Price bigger pieces like crates, beds, cat trees and aquariums on their own, because buyers check them closely.

What pet items should not be sold used?

Do not sell opened food, medication, flea or tick products, anything recalled, crates and carriers with broken latches, leaking aquariums, or heavily chewed beds and fabric items that cannot be washed clean.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.