Skip to main content
Selling

How to Price Pocket Knives at a Garage Sale

Most pocket knives sell for $1-$5 (promo and no-name folders) to $5-$20 (common Swiss Army and Buck folders) at a garage sale. Older USA-made Case, Buck, Schrade, Old Timer and Camillus knives with clean tang stamps and intact handles are the exception - they can bring $20-$150+, so pull those out and check sold listings first. For the wider category, see the Tools & Garage price guide.

Pocket knife price chart

Typical garage sale prices for pocket knives. Condition, maker and tang stamp move the price within each range; for anything that looks collectible, check sold listings first.

ItemTypical garage sale priceNotes
Promo and no-name folding knives$1-$5Giveaway and hardware-store knives; sell as a lot if you have many
Victorinox / Swiss Army knives$5-$20Common 51mm models at the bottom; rarer or vintage models check sold listings
Buck 110 and other Buck folders$10-$40The 110 is a classic; check the model number and condition
Case XX knives (tang stamp dating)$20-$150+Date the XX number from the tang stamp; bone and stag handles sell at the top
Old Timer / Schrade USA$15-$100USA stamps and bone handles matter; check sold listings for the exact model
Camillus and other vintage USA makers$15-$100+WWII-era and earlier knives with clean stamps; collectors buy these
Multi-tools (Leatherman / Gerber)$10-$40Working condition matters; check the model and included tools
Boxed or unused knivesTop of range or moreOriginal box and paperwork add real value; price accordingly
Coffee can lot of mixed knives$10-$30Price the lot, but pull out any USA-made or bone-handled knives first

Is it a valuable pocket knife? A quick check

Run these checks before you tag a knife. They separate a $3 folder from a $100 collector piece:

  • Tang stamp: read the maker name and any "USA" stamp on the blade tang - this is the single most important value marker.
  • Case tang-stamp dot dating: the dot pattern and XX number on a Case tang stamp date the knife; older dates are worth more.
  • Bone or stag handles vs plastic: natural handles on an old knife add significant value over plastic.
  • Blade wear: light sharpening is normal, but a blade ground down thin or with a short, re-ground point has lost value.
  • Snap and walk-and-talk: open and close the knife - a crisp snap and smooth action matter to collectors.
  • Original box and paperwork: a knife in its box with any papers is worth noticeably more than a loose one.
  • No broken tips or cracked handles: a broken tip or cracked handle cuts the value sharply.
  • If the knife passes these checks and looks rare, check sold listings and offer it to collectors or at a flea market rather than pricing it at the table.

Selling knives safely at a garage sale

Keep all knives closed in a tray or display case near the cash table where you can watch them, sell knives only to adults, and check your local rules on blade types before you display them. Keep the display general - a closed knife in a tray is easy for shoppers to browse without handling. For more on what to keep out of a sale, see what not to sell at a garage sale and garage sale safety tips.

Use these free tools

Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.

Frequently asked questions

How much is an old Case pocket knife worth?

A used Case knife in good shape with a clean tang stamp usually sells for $20-$150+ at a garage sale, depending on the date, handle material and condition. Bone and stag handles and older dates sell at the top. Check the XX number on the tang stamp and compare recent sold listings before you price it.

Are Swiss Army knives worth anything used?

Common used Victorinox Swiss Army knives usually sell for $5-$20 at a garage sale. Rarer models, vintage examples or knives in their original box can be worth more, so check the model and sold listings before you tag one. A standard 51mm model is a $5-$10 item.

How can I tell how old a Case knife is?

Read the tang stamp. Case knives carry an XX number and a dot pattern on the tang that date the blade; collectors use these to identify the era. Look the number up against a Case tang-stamp dating chart, then check sold listings for knives from that period.

Should I sharpen or clean a knife before selling it?

Lightly clean the blade and handles so the knife looks presentable, but do not sharpen a collectible knife - grinding the blade removes material collectors pay for. If the knife looks like a collector piece, leave it as-is and note its condition in the listing.

How do I sell a lot of mixed pocket knives?

Pull out any USA-made knives with clean tang stamps, bone handles or original boxes and price those individually. Sell the rest as a coffee-can lot for $10-$30, with a sign that says what is in the lot. This way the good knives get their value and the rest clears quickly.

Keep reading

Free to join. We never post on your behalf.