Condition, maker marks and the gallon number on a crock decide the price, so look at the base of each piece before you tag it. For glass and kitchenware instead, see pricing Pyrex, glassware and china. Brightly coloured Art Deco dinnerware marked "fiesta" has its own guide: is Fiestaware worth anything.
How much should I charge for pottery at a garage sale?
These are starting prices for clean pieces with no chips or cracks. Adjust down for damage, and check sold listings before pricing anything with a maker name you do not recognize.
| Item | Typical garage sale price | Worth more if |
|---|---|---|
| Unmarked vase or planter | $1-$5 | A maker mark, unusual glaze or large size |
| Everyday stoneware dishes and bowls | $2-$8 | A complete set or a known maker |
| McCoy, Hull or Roseville-style planter | $5-$25 | A clear maker mark, original glaze and no chips |
| Fiesta / Fiestaware plate or bowl | $4-$20 | Early colors such as red or cobalt, little rim wear |
| Fiesta / Fiestaware serving piece or platter | $10-$50+ | Rare color, complete set or original box |
| Salt-glaze crock, 1-2 gallon | $10-$25 | A clear maker oval and gallon number |
| Salt-glaze crock, 3-5 gallon | $20-$60 | Red Wing, Robinson Ransbottom or another named maker |
| Salt-glaze crock, 6+ gallon | $40-$100+ | A strong maker mark, early date and good glaze |
| Stoneware jug or churn | $10-$40+ | A maker mark, original lid and a gallon number |
| Studio or handmade pottery | $5-$30+ | A signed bottom, known potter or unusual glaze |
Is it collectible pottery? The checklist
Most pottery is everyday kitchenware worth a few dollars. These details tell you whether a piece is collectible before you put a price on it:
- Maker mark or stamp on the base — Red Wing, McCoy, Hull, Roseville, Fiesta and named studio potters all add value. If the piece is a cookie jar, see what old cookie jars are worth for McCoy, Shawnee and character jar prices.
- Crock gallon number and maker oval — a salt-glaze crock with a clear gallon number and an oval maker mark sells for more than an unmarked one.
- Cracks, chips and hairlines — any damage cuts the price sharply, especially on crocks and jugs.
- Crazing — fine cracks in the glaze are common on old stoneware and lower the price, but do not make a piece unsellable.
- Glaze colour — strong, even glaze and rare colors bring more; worn or rubbed glaze brings less.
How to display and sell pottery
Wash each piece and let it dry, but do not scrub marks, stamps or original labels off the base. Packing matters: pottery breaks easily, so wrap sold pieces in newspaper or bubble wrap.
Put crocks and jugs low and steady, where they cannot be knocked over, and keep small planters and bowls together on one table. Group Fiesta by color so shoppers can see the range.
Show the base of anything with a maker mark — turn the piece around or prop it up so the mark is visible without a buyer having to handle it.
Price unmarked everyday pottery to move at $1-$5, and tag marked or named pieces individually with the maker and any gallon number.
For more display and tagging ideas, see the garage sale price guide.
Use these free tools
- Antiques & Collectibles garage sale price list
- Garage sale pricing calculator
- Garage sale price guide
- Bundle pricing calculator
- Printable price stickers
Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.
Frequently asked questions
How much does pottery sell for at a garage sale?
Most everyday pottery sells for $1 to $10 at a garage sale. Marked stoneware crocks, Red Wing, McCoy or Fiesta pieces can bring $15 to $100 or more, depending on maker, size and condition.
Is Red Wing pottery valuable?
Red Wing stoneware can be worth $20 to $100+ at a garage sale when it has a clear maker mark and gallon number; common unmarked crocks sell much closer to $10-$25.
Is McCoy pottery collectible?
Yes — McCoy planters, jars and dinnerware are collectible, with marked pieces often bringing $5 to $25+ depending on the item, glaze and condition. For McCoy cookie jars specifically, see our cookie jar price guide.
Is Fiesta dinnerware worth anything?
Fiesta / Fiestaware plates and bowls usually sell for about $4 to $20, with early colors such as red and cobalt bringing more; rare pieces and complete sets can be worth more.
How do I tell if my crock is valuable?
Look for a maker mark or oval and a gallon number on the base or side, then check condition — cracks, chips and crazing lower the price, while named makers such as Red Wing bring more.
Should I sell pottery online instead of at a garage sale?
Sell everyday pottery at the garage sale to clear it quickly, and list marked Red Wing, McCoy, Fiesta or signed studio pieces online after checking sold listings.
