Franklin Mint sold heavily through mail order and its own catalogs, so huge numbers of plates, figurines and die-cast models are still in circulation and the secondary market is well supplied. Price the common pieces as decor and set aside the few genuinely valuable items. Use the chart below as a starting point, then check the hallmark, the box and recent sold listings. For the wider category, see how to price antiques and collectibles and the antiques and collectibles price guide.
| Franklin Mint piece | Typical garage sale price | What raises the price |
|---|---|---|
| Sterling silver ingots and medals | Silver weight (often $20-$60+) | Sterling stamp, full weight, no damage, original capsule |
| Boxed 1:24 die-cast cars with papers | $15-$60 | Original box, certificate, limited edition, popular model |
| Loose 1:24 die-cast cars | $5-$20 | Clean paint, complete parts, sought-after car |
| Complete chess sets | $20-$80 | All pieces, original board and box, themed set |
| Collector plates | $2-$10 | Complete series, original box, no chips or fading |
| Dolls and figurines | $5-$30 | Original outfit, box, certificate, no damage |
| Pewter figures and tankards | $5-$25 | Maker mark, clean surface, no dents |
| Coins and medals (non-silver) | $2-$15 | Silver content, original packaging, complete set |
| Knives, thimbles and small collectibles | $1-$10 | Complete set, box, themed series |
Which Franklin Mint items are valuable?
The valuable pieces are the ones with real material value or a genuinely limited run. Sterling silver ingots and medals are worth their silver weight, so a heavy ingot can be worth far more than the decorative pieces around it. Boxed 1:24 die-cast cars with their certificate and original packaging, and complete chess sets with every piece and the board, are the other standouts.
Most everything else is common. Collector plates, loose die-cast cars, dolls, pewter figures and non-silver coins were made in large numbers and usually sell for a few dollars each. Check the item itself before you assume a low price, but do not price a common plate or figurine like a rare antique.
- Sterling silver ingots and medals: value follows the silver weight, not the design.
- Boxed 1:24 die-cast cars with papers: the box, certificate and limited edition carry the price.
- Complete chess sets: all pieces plus the original board and box.
- Everything else: price as decor, usually $2-$30 depending on condition.
Sterling silver vs plated and pewter: how do I read the hallmarks?
Look for the word "sterling", "925" or "925/1000" stamped on the piece. Those marks mean solid sterling silver, and the item is worth at least its melt value. A mark such as "silver plate", "EPNS", "EP" or "silver on copper" means plated, which has almost no melt value and sells as decor.
Pewter is a different metal entirely. It is a soft tin alloy, usually marked "pewter" or with a maker's name, and it is not silver. Pewter figures and tankards sell for a few dollars to about $25, while sterling pieces are priced on weight. When a mark is worn or unclear, test with a magnet (sterling is not magnetic) and weigh the piece before you price it as silver.
- Sterling: stamped "sterling", "925" or "925/1000".
- Plated: stamped "silver plate", "EPNS", "EP" or "silver on copper".
- Pewter: a soft tin alloy marked "pewter" or with a maker's name, not silver.
- Weigh sterling pieces and compare with the current silver price before tagging them.
Does the box and certificate matter?
Yes, especially for die-cast cars, chess sets and limited-edition pieces. The original box, certificate of authenticity and any paperwork prove the item is complete and limited, and collectors pay more for a full package than for a loose piece. Keep the box even if it is worn, and store the certificate with the item.
For common plates and figurines the box adds only a little, but it still helps a piece sell faster. A damaged or missing box does not make a common item worthless, so price it as a loose piece and disclose any chips, fading or missing parts.
How do I price and sell Franklin Mint at a garage sale?
Sort first. Put sterling silver, boxed die-cast cars and complete chess sets on their own table with a clear label, and price the common plates, dolls and figurines low in a bundle. Clean each piece, check for chips or dents, and keep sets together.
For the common pieces, use the ranges in the chart and be ready to negotiate. For sterling, weigh the item and check the current silver price before you accept an offer. For the better die-cast cars and chess sets, compare recent sold listings online, because a collector may pay more than a driveway shopper.
Related guides: how to price collector plates, how to price silverware and sterling silver, how to price coins and stamps, how to price dolls and how to price antiques and collectibles.
Use these free tools
- Antiques & Collectibles garage sale price list
- Garage sale pricing calculator
- Garage sale price guide
- Bundle pricing calculator
- Printable price stickers
Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.
Frequently asked questions
Are Franklin Mint collectibles worth anything?
Most are worth modest amounts. Common plates, dolls, pewter and loose die-cast cars sell for about $5-$40 at a garage sale. Sterling silver ingots and medals are worth their silver weight, and boxed 1:24 die-cast cars with papers or complete chess sets can bring $15-$80.
How can I tell if Franklin Mint silver is real sterling?
Look for the word "sterling", "925" or "925/1000" stamped on the piece. Those marks mean solid sterling silver and the item is worth at least its melt value. Marks such as "silver plate", "EPNS" or "EP" mean plated, which has little melt value.
Are Franklin Mint collector plates worth anything?
Most sell for about $2-$10 each at a garage sale. A complete series in its original box with no chips or fading can bring a little more, but common plates are decorative rather than rare.
Do Franklin Mint die-cast cars need the box to be valuable?
The box and certificate help a lot. A boxed 1:24 die-cast car with its papers and a limited-edition mark can bring $15-$60, while the same car loose usually sells for $5-$20.
Should I sell Franklin Mint items at a garage sale or online?
Sell common plates, dolls, pewter and loose cars at the garage sale. Sterling silver, boxed die-cast cars and complete chess sets do better online or with a collector, where buyers search by the exact item and edition.
