Fishing lure price chart
Typical garage sale prices for fishing lures and tackle. Condition, maker and the original box move the price within each range; for anything that looks vintage, check sold listings first.
| Item | Typical garage sale price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Modern plastic crankbaits and spinners | $0.50-$3 each | Common in bulk; price as a lot to move them fast |
| Soft plastics and jigs (bag lots) | $2-$5 per bag | Sell by the bag, not per piece |
| A tackle box full of lures | $5-$25 | Pull out any vintage lures before pricing the box |
| Vintage wooden lure with glass eyes (Heddon, Creek Chub, Pflueger, South Bend) | $20-$200+ | Check the exact model on sold listings first |
| Vintage lures in their original box | Often double the loose price | The box, paper and hardware are part of the value |
| Old metal spoons and Dardevles | $1-$5 each | Collectors pay more for complete, unscratched sets |
| Fly boxes with flies | $3-$15 | Price higher for hand-tied flies in a complete box |
| Rods and reels | See the linked guide | See how to price camping and fishing gear |
Is it a valuable fishing lure? A quick check
Run your thumb over the lure once before it goes in a mixed lot. These marks separate a 50-cent lure from a $100 lure:
- Wood body vs plastic: real wood (often balsa) with a glass-eye lure is a vintage piece; plastic is modern.
- Glass eyes vs painted eyes: glass eyes that sit proud of the body are a vintage sign; flat painted eyes are not.
- Maker names stamped on the lip, propeller or hardware: Heddon, Creek Chub, Pflueger, South Bend, Smith and other names add value.
- The original cardboard or wooden box and paper: a lure in its box can be worth double or more than the loose lure.
- "Cup and screw" or early hardware: early mounting hardware is a collector mark on older lures.
- Paint condition: chipped, scratched or repainted paint lowers the value a lot; a clean, complete lure prices at the top.
How to display and sell tackle at a garage sale
Open the tackle box on the table and spread the lures in an egg carton or small tray so buyers can see each one without digging. Cover the hooks with a piece of cardboard or a hook mat for safety, and keep the vintage wooden lures near the front where a collector can spot them.
Sell the modern lures as lots - a bag of soft plastics for $3, a box of mixed lures for $10 - and give a bundle price that clears the whole box at once. For rare pieces, a garage sale is usually the wrong room: check sold listings and sell them to a collector, at a flea market or online. See how to price items for a flea market and flea markets near you.
Use these free tools
- Sports & Outdoors garage sale price list
- Garage sale pricing calculator
- Garage sale price guide
- Bundle pricing calculator
- Printable price stickers
Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.
Frequently asked questions
How much are old fishing lures worth?
Most old plastic lures are worth about 50 cents to $3 each, or $5 to $25 for a tackle box full. Vintage wooden lures with glass eyes - Heddon, Creek Chub, Pflueger - can be worth $20 to $200+, especially in the original box. Check the exact model on sold listings before you price it.
Should I sell a tackle box full or piece by piece?
Sell the modern lures as a lot - a box of mixed lures for about $10 to $25 - and sell any vintage wooden lures individually after checking sold listings. A single vintage lure can be worth more than the rest of the box combined, so pull those out first.
What vintage lures are worth the most?
Wooden-bodied lures with glass eyes from the 1930s-1950s - Heddon, Creek Chub, Pflueger, South Bend - especially in their original box with the paper and hardware. Rare models and limited runs can be worth $100 to $200+; check the exact model on sold listings before you price it.
Can you sell fishing lures at a yard sale in winter?
You can, but fishing gear sells best in spring when buyers are planning trips. If you sell in winter, price toward the low end and bundle the lures with a rod and reel so the lot looks like a complete starter kit.
Are old tackle boxes collectible?
Some are. Vintage metal tackle boxes from the 1940s-1960s with the original finish and hardware can be worth $20 to $100+ to collectors, while a dented modern box is worth about $5 to $15. Check the brand and condition on sold listings before you price it.
