Plan around your prices and likely first purchases. A table full of $1 toys needs more singles than a sale of $20 furniture. The example below is a practical starting point, then you can adjust the mix with our change calculator.
A simple $110-$120 garage sale cash box breakdown
For a US sale, use twenty $1 bills, eight $5 bills, four $10 bills and $10-$20 in quarters. The bills total $100; the quarters bring your starting float to $110-$120. Skip a starting $20 bill: it ties up money that could be helping you break a buyer's twenty.
| Denomination | Quantity | Total |
|---|---|---|
| $1 bills | 20 | $20 |
| $5 bills | 8 | $40 |
| $10 bills | 4 | $40 |
| Quarters | 40-80 coins | $10-$20 |
| Starting float | All denominations combined | $110-$120 |
Adjust the float for your sale and country
If you expect a busy morning or have several families selling together, work toward $150 by adding more $1s and $5s. For a small sale with whole-dollar prices, about $100 may be enough. Do not turn your whole float into quarters when nothing costs less than a dollar. Ask helpers to use one checkout point so the available change stays together.
In Canada, use loonies and toonies instead of $1 bills, with plenty of $5 bills and a few $10s. Keep quarters if your labels use 25-cent steps. Build toward the same approximate starting range in Canadian dollars, but put more of the float into the coins your prices require. Write down your actual opening total rather than assuming it matches the US example.
Get small bills and coin rolls from your bank the day before the sale, checking branch hours first. Ask whether you need to order change ahead. Count it at home, separate denominations and pack it with the rest of your garage sale supplies checklist.
Price in simple amounts so you need less change
Use $0.25 steps for inexpensive loose items, whole dollars for ordinary goods and $5 steps for larger pieces where the price makes sense. A $1 book or $5 bundle is easier to handle than a $0.95 book or $4.75 bundle. Avoid pennies, nickels and dimes by choosing labels that quarters can cover.
Bundle little items instead of giving each one a tiny price. Try four small toys for $1 or a bag of craft supplies for $5, with the bundle clearly marked. If buyers negotiate, settle on a total you can easily make change for. Our garage sale pricing guide helps you choose reasonable starting prices before simplifying the labels.
A friendly 'small bills appreciated' sign helps, but expect some twenties anyway. If the first buyer offers $100 for a $2 purchase, explain that you cannot break it and ask for a smaller bill or your backup payment option. You do not need enough cash to break every possible note.
Cash box, apron or fanny pack: keep the money with you
A garage sale cash box keeps bills and coins sorted and works well when one helper stays at checkout. Never leave the box alone, even briefly. A lock does not stop someone carrying the whole box away. Hand responsibility to another adult before leaving the table.
A pocketed apron makes change easy to reach while you help shoppers. A zipped fanny pack keeps money close when you move between tables. Separate coins and bills so you can count accurately, and close the pockets between transactions. Choose something comfortable enough to wear all morning.
Move big bills and surplus cash into the house periodically, leaving enough small change for the next customers. Record each transfer and keep it separate from household money. Count at lunch while a trusted helper covers checkout; check whether you need more singles or quarters before the afternoon. See our garage sale safety tips for the rest of your sale-day setup.
For each purchase, say the total and the amount received, then count the change back aloud. Keep the buyer's note separate until you finish, then put it away. Handle one payment at a time so a conversation does not interrupt your count.
Take digital payments as a backup
A phone payment option helps when a buyer lacks cash or you cannot break a large bill. Set it up before sale morning, charge your phone and display the details at checkout. Our garage sale payments guide covers cash, mobile apps and Canadian e-Transfer. Confirm receipt in your own account before handing over the item, and record digital receipts separately from physical cash.
End-of-day counting-up sheet
Once the sale closes, count privately with your helper. Write each denomination, quantity and subtotal on paper, then add the subtotals. Include the money moved into the house earlier. Your float is money you already owned, so subtract it before calling the remainder sales revenue. For a multi-family sale, compare each family's recorded sales before dividing the proceeds, and return the float to whoever supplied it.
| Counting sheet line | Example |
|---|---|
| Cash left in box, apron or pack | $240 |
| Add cash moved into the house | + $100 |
| Subtract recorded starting float | - $120 |
| Cash sales revenue | $220 |
| Add digital receipts after fees | + $60 |
| Total sales revenue after payment fees | $280 |
Use these free tools
Ready to list your sale? Post your sale free and put it on the local map.
Frequently asked questions
How much change should I have for a yard sale?
Start with about $100-$150 in small bills and coins. A useful US mix is twenty $1s, eight $5s, four $10s and $10-$20 in quarters, totaling $110-$120. Add more singles and fives for a busy sale.
Should I get quarters for a garage sale?
Yes, if you price items in 25-cent increments. About $10-$20 in quarters is a useful starting supply. If every price is a whole dollar, put more of your float into small bills instead.
Where do I get small bills for a garage sale?
Ask your bank for small bills and coin rolls the day before the sale. Check its hours and whether change needs ordering ahead, then count and separate the denominations before sale morning.
Does my starting cash float count as garage sale earnings?
No. Add the cash left at checkout to any cash moved into the house, then subtract your recorded opening float to find cash sales revenue. Add digital receipts separately and deduct any sale expenses when calculating your net proceeds.
